A cluster randomised trial of cloth masks compared with. How to design, analyse and report cluster randomised trials. Flow diagram of the progress through the phases of a parallel randomized trial of two groups 6 randomized controlled field trial. Updates in clinical research methodology march 18, 20 supported by nidcr grants de016750, de016752. These problems are not commonly recognised by many researchers. Steppedwedge cluster randomised trials swcrt are increasingly being used in health policy and services research, but unless they are conducted and reported to the highest methodological standards, they are unlikely to be useful to decisionmakers. By making reporting guidelines for this innovative design. In this companion paper we focus on sample size calculations for cluster randomised trials and on the methods for statistical analyses of these studies. A separate consort statement for the reporting of abstracts was published in 2008. The statement was revised in 2001, with a further update in 2010.
Participants were followed during the same calendar time for 4 weeks of facemasks use. Pdf analysis of cluster randomized trials in primary care. Review of 34 cluster randomised trials in primary care published in 2004 and 2005 in seven journals british medical journal, british journal of general practice, family practice, preventive. Cluster randomised trials epidemiology and psychiatric. This guidance has been extended to cluster randomised trials and also to pragmatic trials 3. Although randomised controlled trials are the reference methodology to assess the effects of therapeutic interventions, for interventions that naturally occur in groups of individuals random allocation of participants may be inappropriate. Cluster randomised trials facilitating quality trials. Design and analysis of cluster randomization trials in. Cluster randomised controlled trials are also known as cluster randomised trials, group randomised trials, and place randomized trials a 2004 bibliometric study documented an increasing number of publications in the. Cluster randomised trials request pdf researchgate. A clusterrandomized trial of bloodpressure reduction in. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation, with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectio. Rct is a type of scientific often medical experiment that aims to reduce certain sources of bias when testing the effectiveness of new treatments. A fundamental assumption of the patient randomised trial.
Identification of the primary study outcome determination of a minimally important effect of the intervention specification of a statistical test or confidence interval method along with its directionality onesided twosided in addition, in cluster randomized trials. Cluster randomised trials are at greater risk of bias, require more participants and demand more statistical sophistication. It is similar to an randomized controlled clinical trial except that the intervention is preventive and not therapeutic. The design and use of cluster randomised controlled trials in. The traditional approach to the analysis of cluster randomized trials has been to calculate a summary measure for each cluster, such as a cluster mean or proportion. Cluster randomized trials and the stepped wedge jim hughes uw biostatistics. The two cluster randomized groups were well balanced across most characteristics, except that a higher percentage of. Cluster randomised controlled trials are also known as cluster randomised trials, group randomised trials, and placerandomized trials. In the field of hospital epidemiology, the clusterrandomized trial crt. This website is designed to support those conducting cluster randomised trials and stepped wedge designs and those carrying out methodological research on these designs.
Analysis of cluster randomized trials in primary care. But this strategy is typical of many cluster randomized trials. The increasing use of cluster randomised trials in lowresource settings raises unique ethical issues. In health care, these trials often compare different ways of managing a disease or promoting healthy living, in contrast to conventional randomised trials which randomise individuals to different treatments, classically comparing new drugs with a. Dec 15, 2016 the healthy lifestyles programme help trial is being conducted to determine whether a novel schoolbased intervention is effective and costeffective in preventing obesity in 910 yearold children. Please do not bookmark this login page, try going to the application you wanted to access. In this paper, we seek to identify any gaps in the. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation, with special attention given to evaluating. Cluster randomised trials crts are becoming increasingly important in health technology assessment. Elsewhere1 we have described the rationale for carrying out cluster randomised controlled trials crcts in injury prevention and discussed key issues relating to the design and ethical conduct of such studies. However, the clusters are balanced at the individual level only if all eligible people, or a random sample, within the cluster are included in the trial. The ottawa statement on the ethical design and conduct of cluster randomised trials is the first international ethical guidance document specific to cluster trials, but it is unknown if it adequately addresses issues in lowresource settings. Sample size formulae for pairmatched studies in individually randomized trials, the number of subjects random ized is generally large enough to ensure close comparability of the treatment groups. A cluster randomised trial of medical and cloth mask use for hcws was conducted in 14 hospitals in hanoi, vietnam.
Cluster randomised trials are trials in which groups or clusters of individuals are randomly allocated to different forms of treatment. Cluster randomised trials crts involve randomisation of groups clusters of individuals to control or intervention conditions. Design and analysis of stepped wedge cluster randomized trials michael a. Jan 12, 2012 this book is intended as a practical guide, written for researchers from the health professions including doctors, psychologists, and allied health professionals, as well as statisticians involved in the design, execution, analysis and reporting of cluster randomised trials. Jan 18, 2019 the consolidated standards of reporting trials consort statement for individually randomised controlled trials provides guidance for reporting results from a randomised trial. Jul 04, 2011 cluster randomised trials discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of health trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. Open access research a cluster randomised trial of cloth. Simple sample size calculation for clusterrandomized trials. Common examples of clusters are hospitals and general practices, where all the individuals in each cluster would receive the same intervention. Cluster randomized trials, in which health interventions are allocated randomly to intact clusters or communities rather than to individual subjects, are increasingly being used to evaluate disease control strategies both in industrialized and in developing countries. Pdf cluster randomized trials increasingly are being used in health services research and in primary care, yet the majority of these trials do not. Pdf on oct 1, 2004, c raina elley and others published randomised trials cluster versus individual randomisation.
Making the cluster a lot larger while keeping the number of clusters fixed might yield only a very small increase in power and precision, owing to the intracluster correlation. A cluster randomized trial crt is a trial in which individuals are randomized in groupsthe group as a whole is randomized and not the individual. Clinical outcomes of staff training in positive behaviour support to reduce challenging behaviour in adults with intellectual disability. Design effect d is the increase in sample size over individual randomization required to compensate for intra cluster correlation estimated by intra cluster correlation coefficient or coefficient of variation. Thus, the purpose of this cluster randomised controlled trial rct was to test the effect of a singleexercise approach, based on the ca, to reduce the prevalence of groin problems in male players. Pdf over the last century, the randomized clinical trial has become the gold standard for interventional studies. However, cluster randomised trials in which groups of subjects are allocated to different treatments are becoming increasingly popular. Cluster unit randomized trials office of behavioral and. Cluster randomised trials are well suited and are now commonly used to evaluate public health, health policy and health system interventions. Cluster randomised trials are useful for evaluating interventions delivered at the level of the cluster or when there is a risk that individual randomisation will result in contamination of treatments between arms. The adductor strengthening programme prevents groin. Cluster randomised trials pose a different challenge. Crt designs are used not only to evaluate group interventions but also individual interventions where group level effects are relevant.
Sample size estimates for clusterrandomized trials in hospital. East london randomised controlled trial for high risk asthma. Clinical outcomes of staff training in positive behaviour. Analysis and reporting of stepped wedge randomised controlled trials. Cluster randomised trials, second edition discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. The healthy lifestyles programme help trial is being conducted to determine whether a novel schoolbased intervention is effective and costeffective in preventing obesity in 910 yearold children. An extension of the consort reporting guideline for swcrts has recently been developed. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectious diseases. A brief history of the cluster randomised trial design sage journals. Physicians, group practices, health plans, or even geographic regions counties or states can be defined as clusters. Recognize when cluster randomization should be preferred to individual. Cluster randomised trials can be susceptible to a range of methodological problems. Cluster randomized trials randomization at group level.
Detailed statistical analysis plan for a cluster randomised. Cluster randomised trials second edition pdf ammedicine. Facemasks and hand hygiene to prevent influenza transmission in households. Omar, michael king, rachael hunter, asit biswas, viv. To determine whether asthma specialist nurses, using a liaison model of. Reports of trials must conform to consort 2010 guidelines. In health care, these trials often compare different ways of managing a disease or promoting healthy living, in contrast to conventional randomised trials which randomise individuals to different treatments, classically comparing new drugs with a placebo. Ethical issues raised by cluster randomised trials conducted. Factors influencing loss of precision cluster randomization trials 1. The use of the steppedwedge cluster randomised trial swcrt is on the increase, and although there are still relatively few swcrts currently published its use is bound to show an increase in the near future. Because each cluster then provides only one data point, the data can be considered to be independent, allowing standard statistical tests to be used.
We did this openlabel, cluster randomised trial direct at 49 primary care practices in scotland and the tyneside region of england. Apr 22, 2015 a cluster randomised trial of cloth masks compared with medical masks in healthcare workers c raina macintyre, 1 holly seale, 1 tham chi dung, 2 nguyen tran hien, 2 phan thi nga, 2 abrar ahmad chughtai, 1 bayzidur rahman, 1 dominic e dwyer, 3 and quanyi wang 4. In earlier papers we considered the implications of the 2001 version of the consort statement for the reporting of cluster randomised trial. Most randomised trials allocate individual participants to different treatments. How to design efficient cluster randomised trials the bmj. Cluster randomised trials discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of health trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. Pdf randomised trialscluster versus individual randomisation.
The method of randomization for clusterrandomized trials. Cluster randomized trial an overview sciencedirect topics. Cluster randomised trials, second edition johns hopkins. The need for consent by individual study subjects is deemed of particular concern for individual cluster trials. Advantages and disadvantages of various randomized clinical.
Some methodological issues in the design and analysis of. Cluster randomized trials crt in which the unit of randomization is a group of participants 3,4, or cluster are relevant for interventions applied at the level of the group, and may offer some advantages in trials enrolling participants with mcc. Introduction and scope cluster randomised trials crts are becoming increasingly important in health technology assessment. Grouprandomized also known as cluster randomized trials are those trials where the unit of randomization is one of the several types of groups rather than an individual. This article describes the detailed statistical analysis plan for the help trial, including an amendment and rationale for amendment made to originally planned sensitivity analyses. Pdf how to design efficient cluster randomised trials researchgate. Articles efficacy and effectiveness of an rvsvvectored. Trial design the peptic study is a prospective, multicentre, randomised, openlabel, cluster crossover, registryembedded trial comparing two approaches to stress ulcer prophylaxis in mechanically ventilated adults implemented at the level of the icu. Methodological bias in cluster randomised trials bmc. A cluster randomized trial article pdf available in annals of internal medicine 1517.
Pdf cluster randomised trials have diminishing returns in power and precision as cluster size increases. Advantages and disadvantages of various randomized. A randomized controlled trial or randomized control trial. The consort extension for cluster trials was updated in 2012 to be inline with consort 2010 and is available for download below. Baseline characteristics of the barbershops and trial participants. Pdf cluster randomised trials methodological and ethical. Endnote or other referencing software, and your figures as editable files eg. Cluster sample size calculator guide introduction cluster randomised trials involve randomisation of groups of individuals such as randomisation by general practice, hospital ward or health professional.
Sample size in cluster randomized trials cluster randomized trials increase sample size requirements due to intra cluster correlation. In such trials, participants are randomised in groups rather than as individuals, where the group is the cluster. A cluster randomised controlled trial is a type of randomised controlled trial in which groups of subjects as opposed to individual subjects are randomised. This work is licensed under a creative commons attribution.
The trial started on the 3 march 2011, with rolling recruitment undertaken between 3 march 2011 and 10 march 2011. Baseline testing in cluster randomised controlled trials. It explores the advantages of cluster randomization, with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectious diseases. The main consort statement provides recommendations for reporting parallel group randomized trials, in which individual participants are randomly assigned to health care interventions. Cluster unit randomized trials the office of behavioral. Jul 14, 2017 cluster randomised trials have diminishing returns in power and precision as cluster size increases.
Pdf methodological bias in cluster randomised trials. Pdf facemasks and hand hygiene to prevent influenza. Randomised trials are subject to random chance confounding 8 as randomisation does not prevent confounding by baseline risk factors, but it only makes confounding random. Main cluster randomised trials cluster randomised trials are when participants are randomised as intact groups rather than as individuals. Cluster randomization trials crts are experimental studies in which intact social units.
The method is commonly used in educational interventions, where a school or class is the unit of allocation 1, and evaluation of activities. Our aim is to promote good quality research and so we encourage the use of existing guidelines and methods. A practical guide to cluster randomised trials in health. Its use is likely to grow as we move towards the learning healthcare system2 and large simple trials. In cluster randomized trials, however, the number of clusters randomized is often small sometimes.
A randomized controlled trial rct is a way of doing impact evaluation in which the population receiving. Stepped wedge cluster randomized designs for disease. This article describes the detailed statistical analysis plan for the help trial, including an amendment and rationale for amendment made to originally planned. Selection bias in cluster trials properly randomised cluster trials should not be biased at baseline. Cluster randomised trials second edition discusses the design conduct and analysis of trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. In this paper we discuss the issues that can lead to bias in cluster trials. Design and analysis of cluster randomization trials in health. This is where the cluster randomized trial design comes in.
Methods study design and participants this cluster rct was registered with the international standard randomised controlled trial. Cluster randomised trials, where groups of patients rather than individuals are randomised, are increasingly being used in health services research. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation, with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectious diseases. Methods and analysis 480 patients aged 1865 with an international classification of diseases diagnosis. Design and analysis of stepped wedge cluster randomized trials.
75 761 970 468 895 787 1048 1101 1354 1574 1104 1299 654 1125 833 1161 1502 877 1248 836 1316 270 1180 1154 1197 1 1425 860 529 51 880 1379 720 703 591 1464